The Twice-a-Year Check-In Every Pastor Needs
Strategy Comes Before Tactics: Long-term ministry health starts with a clear direction, not with reacting to whatever problem is loudest this week.
An Annual Audit Has Two Halves: An holistic evaluation covers your personal life, family, finances, and rhythms, right alongside your church's vision, finances, and leadership health.
Knowing Isn't Doing: Recognizing you should change something means nothing until it's built into an actual rhythm on your calendar.
Multiplication Trumps Management: God measures faithfulness by what you did with what you were given, not by how little you risked losing.
When my dad (a pastor of 40 years) talks about ministry longevity, he often tells the story of his friend, Mark - a Christian leader and avid hiker.
While on a once-in-a-lifetime trip to Scotland, Mark set out early one morning to climb the Scottish mountain Munro Driesh, a hike known for its stunning views. The Scottish mountains come with their own weather, so from the moment he set out, most of Mark's climb was through mist.
Because he was sure of his route, he pushed through the mist all morning.
Want more from The Lead Pastor?
Sign up for a free membership to complete reading this article:
Have an account? Log In
It wasn't until the clouds finally broke at noon that he realized he was halfway up Munro Mayar, a nearby peak. He’d climbed the wrong mountain.
There’s nothing more tragic than realizing after years of pastoring, you successfully achieved the wrong set of goals.
Like Mark, we can be sincere and committed, all the while pushing towards the wrong achievement. In the day-to-day grind of ministry, it’s easy to mistake movement for progress. That is why we need a regular "check-in" to make sure we are working towards the right ends.
The Twice-a-Year Check-In
To prevent that from happening, my dad has built a habit of a semi-annual ministry audit. It’s about taking a deliberate, planned, strategic pause, twice a year, to ensure your current direction aligns with your calling.
Free Download: The Ministry Audit
I built the Personal Ministry Audit worksheet for that exact check.
Book a day away, twice a year. Step off the trail, and clearly evaluate your surroundings. Spend the time to get a clear read on where you actually are, and the direction you’re working towards.
Does it align with where God’s directed you?
- Schedule a dedicated day: Block one full day twice a year and protect it with the same priority as a board meeting or Sunday sermon.
- Begin with reflection: Start alone with God to pray and listen without rushing to solve problems immediately.
- Evaluate personal health: Complete the personal health section first, assessing areas such as spiritual life, emotional health, and family.
- Evaluate church health: Complete the church health section second, looking at mission clarity, leadership health, and community impact.
- Seek outside input: Ask your spouse and a trusted ministry leader for honest feedback on what you might be missing in yourself and the church.
- Commit to concrete actions: Conclude the day by deciding on one personal action and one church action to implement over the next six months.
- Plan ahead: Before the day ends, put the date for your next six-month audit on your calendar.
The goal of this process is not to achieve a perfect score but to foster the radical honesty required for meaningful change. By documenting evidence-based answers and identifying specific "stop-doing" items, we can ensure our pastoral efforts remain focused on fulfilling our calling.
This guides you through an honest read on your current direction, and leads you to identify one or two 'course correct' decisions. Here's a more complete breakdown:
Knowing you should stop to confirm direction is one thing. Doing it is another.
I know from personal experience: good intentions can easily get shuffled down the church management priority list during the relentless grind of sermon after sermon, budget meeting upon budget meeting, crisis upon crisis.
The mist clears for everyone eventually. This worksheet just asks you to clear it on purpose, twice a year, instead of waiting to find out which mountain you've been climbing.