The 12 Commandments of Making Church Leadership Fun For Youth
In youth ministry, making church leadership fun for youth is easier said than done. You’ve likely tried different methods, but the results don’t always last:
- You see students sign up for leadership roles but lose steam after just a few weeks.
- You catch yourself doing most of the work because it feels easier than keeping them motivated.
- You struggle to build momentum that keeps leadership fun and meaningful.
In my experience, these problems show up when we assume energy alone is enough to carry a student team. But without clear effective church management tools, leadership strategies, practical tips, and fresh ideas, excitement wears off fast—and you end up carrying the weight on your own.
Making Church Leadership Fun for Youth: TLDR
I want to help you develop a youth leadership ministry team that stays energized, feels ownership, and grows as young leaders in your church. That’s why I’ve pulled together this roundup of youth ministry tips and best practices for making church leadership fun for youth:
- Make it safe first, fun second.
- Train adult leaders to protect fun, not kill it.
- Allow 'fun' to serve the mission, not replace it.
- Teach while they move.
- Stay flexible (but don't compromise accountability)
- Be real, or be replaced
- Don't wait to let them lead.
- Train them to build a culture of welcome.
- Help them to reach beyond their comfort zone
- Teach biblical hospitality.
- Be pro-community, but anti-clique.
- Eagerly support your parents.
Most teens aren’t showing up wondering how they can become spiritual leaders. They show up looking for something to do, a place to belong, and people who actually notice they exist:
1. Make It Safe First, Fun Second
Fun often opens the door to deeper things, but if you stop there, you’ll miss the real opportunity God’s given you. The goal isn’t just to hold their attention. It’s to help them find their place in God’s mission.
If students don’t feel safe, they won’t come back—no matter how much pizza you order or how loud the music gets. Of course, physical safety has to be non-negotiable.
- Lock any unused rooms.
- Run background checks on every adult who volunteers.
- Keep activities visible, with no dark corners or hidden spaces.
Emotional safety matters just as much, though it’s easier to overlook when the room feels busy and full. Don’t let students get mocked, excluded, or manipulated by peers or leaders.
Remember: You’re not just managing behavior, you’re shaping culture.
2. Train Adults to Protect Fun Without Killing It
You don’t need more clipboard carriers standing in the back with their arms crossed. You need leaders who understand how to step in when safety is at risk, but know how to let students be themselves when it’s not.
Kids are loud. They move fast. They test boundaries. These things aren't problems: they're opportunities to engage.
Train your adults to spread out, engage students, and build trust long before there’s ever a problem to fix.
3. Let Fun Serve the Mission, Not Replace It
Fun makes the room feel lighter. It builds trust, lowers walls, and creates moments where students let their guard down long enough to hear the truth they’ve been avoiding.
Don’t confuse keeping kids busy with helping them grow. Use games, music, and shared experiences to move them toward spiritual conversations—not away from them.
When you lead with clarity about what matters most, your students will begin to care about what matters most, too.
4. Teach While They Move
The average teenager isn’t wired to sit still and listen like they’re in a seminary lecture... so, if your teaching is just a longer version of the announcements, you’ve already lost them.
Get them moving. Bring them into the teaching moment. Use what’s already in the room. Jesus used bread, fish, birds, fig trees, and mustard seeds. You can use dodgeballs, ping-pong tables, and phones.
Don’t just tell them truth—help them interact with it in ways they’ll remember.
5. Stay Flexible Without Sacrificing Accountability
Every youth ministry has its own rhythm: some groups love high-energy games. Others would rather hang out and talk... what works this semester might completely flop next year when your seniors graduate and your group dynamic shifts.
Experiment often—but never throw accountability out the window to make your numbers look good.
- Get permission slips signed for every offsite activity.
- Keep your budget open to oversight.
- Run your plans by your lead pastor or board before you announce them.
Protect your integrity before you ever have to defend it.
6. Be Real or Be Replaced
Students don’t need you to be cool—they need you to show up as yourself. This generation has been marketed at since they could talk. They can spot fake smiles and forced energy a mile away.
What they respect is honesty, consistency, and leaders who actually care enough to stay when things get messy.
7. Don’t Wait to Let Them Lead
Leadership isn’t something they graduate into when they turn 18. It’s something they learn by doing—right now, right here, in the messiness of real ministry.
The longer you wait to let students take ownership, the less ownership they’ll ever feel.
Start small:
- Let them greet at the door.
- Let them run the slides.
- Let them lead games, read Scripture, or serve snacks.
- Let them assist in youth fundraisers and other important events.
8. Train Youth Leaders to Build a Culture of Welcome
Start by making “welcome” a leadership expectation, not just a personality trait.
Teach your student leaders that greeting people, learning names, and inviting others into the circle is youth discipleship. It’s not extra work - it's THE work.
Remind them that Romans 15:7 says, “Accept one another, then, just as Christ accepted you, in order to bring praise to God.”
Help them see how every “Hey, come sit with us” moment builds Christ-like character and opens the door for someone to experience the love of Jesus—sometimes before they ever hear a sermon.
9. Train them to reach beyond their comfort zone
Hospitality isn’t just for greeters or adults - it’s for every student leader. Here’s how you build it into your training:
- Teach them to notice who’s on the outside looking in.
- Train them to initiate conversations with new students—without waiting for adults to do it first.
- Help them see that leading games, small groups, or worship isn’t more important than simply being available to the student who’s standing alone.
Make “creating a safe and welcoming space” part of the win for every leader.
10. Teach Biblical Hospitality
Hospitality runs all through Scripture:
- Jesus welcomed children when the disciples tried to push them away (Matthew 19:14).
- The early church opened homes, shared meals, and invited strangers in (Acts 2:46–47).
- Paul reminded the church to show hospitality to strangers, because some have “entertained angels without knowing it” (Hebrews 13:2).
These aren’t random stories; they are patterns of leadership we’re called to follow. Ensure that the youth ministry curriculum you're using teaches that when youth leaders open their circle to someone new, they're doing kingdom work.
11. Be Pro-Community, But Anti-Clique
Nothing shrinks a youth group quite like cliques. When students walk in and consistently feel like outsiders, they’ll stop showing up. But when students are greeted by name, invited in, and given space to belong, your youth group will grow, as:
- They bring their friends.
- They talk about it at school.
- They build a community that reflects the diversity of your city, not just the comfort zone of your core group.
A culture of welcome breaks down walls that age, race, background, and personality put up.
That’s how you build a kingdom-minded community, not just a youth group that looks like your leadership team.
12. Eagerly Support Your Parents
Youth ministry should never replace parenting; rather, it should support and encourage parents. Build intentional touch-points with parents, not just students.
Here’s how:
- Invite parents to a yearly vision night or parent orientation.
- Provide conversation guides or follow-up questions after big events or series.
- Encourage parents to volunteer, not just to chaperone, but to engage and learn alongside their kids.
Remind parents that Deuteronomy 6:6–7 calls them to impress God’s truth on their children as they sit, walk, lie down, and get up.
Your Doing MORE Than Making Church Leadership Fun for Your Youth.
Making church leadership fun for youth isn’t about creating a room full of noise that keeps them distracted. It’s about building a pipeline of leaders who prioritize meaningful discipleship relationships. These leaders will serve the church long after you’ve handed the baton to someone else.
You’re not just entertaining students—you’re raising pastors, teachers, parents, and disciple-makers.
And if you do this with courage, clarity, and care, you’ll see fruit that lasts far beyond this season.
Join TheLeadPastor.com Newsletter
If this hit home for you, I’d love to keep the conversation going.
I write a regular email for pastors like you—leaders who care more about people than platforms, who want real tools, not recycled theories. It’s packed with practical resources, honest encouragement, and lessons I’m learning in the trenches of local church leadership.
Sign up here, and let’s keep building healthy churches together.
