16 Best Church Insurance Providers Reviewed in 2025
10 Best Church Insurance Providers Shortlist
Here’s my shortlist of the best church insurance providers:
Get free help from our service advisors to find your match.
A church faces unique risks that require thoughtful protection—whether it’s safeguarding property, caring for your congregation, or handling legal liabilities. Insurance tailored to ministry needs is essential, but sorting through your options can be confusing and time-consuming.
The right provider goes beyond basic coverage by offering peace of mind and a deeper understanding of how churches operate. Based on my research and experience, I’ve reviewed some of the top church insurance providers to help simplify your decision-making process.
This article highlights my top picks, explaining what makes each one stand out. The goal is to provide clear, unbiased insights so you can find the best fit for your church’s specific needs.
Need expert help selecting the right tool?
With one-on-one help, we guide you to your top software options. Narrow down your software search & make a confident choice.
Why Trust Our Reviews
We’ve been testing and reviewing church management software and services since 2019. As church managers ourselves, we know how critical and difficult it is to make the right decision when selecting a provider. We invest in deep research to help our audience make better purchasing decisions.
We’ve tested more than 2,000 tools and hundreds of service providers for different church management use cases, and written over 1,000 comprehensive reviews. Learn how we stay transparent & check out our review methodology.
Best Church Insurance Providers Summary
This comparison chart summarizes pricing details for my top church insurance providers selections to help you find the best one for your budget and business needs.
| Service | Best For | Trial Info | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Best for online quotes | No trial or free demo available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 2 | Best for small churches in Canada | No trial or free demo available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 3 | Best for large churches | No trial or free demo available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 4 | Best for tech-savvy churches | Free personalized consultation available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 5 | Best for Episcopal churches | Request a personalized insurance proposal | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 6 | Best for California churches | Free personalized consultation available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 7 | Best for nonprofit churches | Request a personalized insurance proposal | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 8 | Best for risk management | Free personalized consultation available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 9 | Best for personal service | Free personalized consultation available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 10 | Best for legal assistance | Free consultation available | Customized price upon request | Website |
Best Church Insurance Providers Reviews
Below are my detailed summaries of the best church insurance providers that made it onto my shortlist. My reviews offer a look at each provider’s key services, unique specialties, and pros & cons to help you find the best one for your needs.
Progressive Commercial offers a range of insurance products tailored to churches and religious organizations, focusing on property, liability, and workers' compensation coverage. Their main client base is religious institutions seeking reliable protection for their assets and activities.
Why I picked Progressive Commercial: Progressive Commercial provides an easy-to-use online quoting system that simplifies the insurance selection process for your team. This feature helps you quickly compare different coverage options and find the best fit for your needs. Their focus on accessibility and convenience makes them a strong choice for churches looking to streamline their insurance purchasing experience.
Standout Services: They provide business owner's policy (BOP) that combines property and liability insurance into one package, offering a cost-effective solution for your church. Additionally, their commercial auto insurance covers vehicles used for church activities, ensuring your transportation needs are met safely.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, small businesses, non-profits, and educational institutions
Specialties: Online quotes, property insurance, liability coverage, workers' compensation, and commercial auto insurance
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Strong financial stability
- Customizable policy bundles
- Nationwide availability
- Wide range of coverage options
- Easy online quoting system
Cons:
- Customer service can vary by location
- May not offer specialized church coverages
- Limited focus on large organizations
- No free trial or discovery offers
- Pricing details not publicly available
JD Smith Insurance specializes in providing insurance solutions tailored to churches and non-profit organizations. They focus on offering services like property and liability coverage, primarily serving small churches across Canada.
Why I picked JD Smith Insurance: JD Smith Insurance offers tailored packages that cater specifically to the needs of small churches, emphasizing unique coverages not typically found in standard commercial policies. Their dedication to understanding church-specific requirements sets them apart. They provide specialized services like counselors malpractice and sexual abuse liability coverage, making them an ideal choice for smaller church communities.
Standout Services: They offer non-profit directors & officers insurance, which is crucial for protecting your leadership team from personal liability. Additionally, their sport shield accident policy covers injuries during church events, ensuring your community activities are safeguarded.
Target industries: Churches, non-profit organizations, health and fitness, contractors, and retail
Specialties: Property coverage, liability coverage, cyber liability, event insurance, and claims prevention
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Comprehensive liability options
- Special focus on Canadian churches
- Discounts for church staff
- Unique coverages not standard elsewhere
- Tailored packages for small churches
Cons:
- Application process could be more streamlined
- Primarily focused on Canadian market
- May not serve larger organizations well
- Limited information on trial offers
- Pricing details not readily available
Nationwide Insurance offers a variety of insurance products tailored to churches, focusing on property, liability, and workers' compensation coverage. They mainly serve large churches and religious organizations looking for reliable protection for their assets and activities.
Why I picked Nationwide Insurance: Nationwide Insurance caters specifically to the needs of large churches, providing extensive coverage options that address the complexities of managing bigger congregations. Their services include specialized liability coverage and property protection, ensuring your church's assets are safeguarded. This focus on larger institutions means you can rely on them for comprehensive support tailored to your unique needs.
Standout Services: They offer cyber liability insurance to protect your church from data breaches and cyber threats, which is essential for maintaining trust in your online activities. Additionally, their employment practices liability insurance covers legal costs for employment-related claims, helping your church manage potential risks associated with staffing.
Target industries: Large churches, religious organizations, schools, charities, and non-profits
Specialties: Property coverage, liability insurance, workers' compensation, cyber liability, and risk management
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Strong financial backing
- Nationwide presence
- Provides cyber liability protection
- Offers extensive liability coverage
- Tailored for large churches
Cons:
- Detailed information requires direct inquiry
- May not suit non-religious entities
- No trial options available
- Limited focus on smaller churches
- Pricing details not publicly available
Lightwell Insurance offers specialized services for churches and Christian ministries, focusing on church insurance, employee benefits, HR services, and payroll services. Their main client base includes faith-based organizations seeking comprehensive protection and support.
Why I picked Lightwell Insurance: Lightwell Insurance caters to tech-savvy churches by providing resources like risk management articles and podcasts, which help your team stay informed and prepared. Their emphasis on integrating technology into their offerings ensures that you have access to the latest tools and information. This focus on tech-enabled solutions makes them a great choice for churches looking to leverage technology in their operations.
Standout Services: They provide employee benefits services that help your church manage staff benefits, ensuring satisfaction and retention. Their HR services offer support for managing personnel, helping your team address human resources challenges effectively.
Target industries: Churches, Christian ministries, schools, camps, and mission teams
Specialties: Church insurance, employee benefits, HR services, payroll services, and risk management
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Nationwide agent availability
- Tailored for faith-based organizations
- Offers HR and payroll services
- Strong focus on customer service
- Tech-enabled resources
Cons:
- Detailed information requires direct inquiry
- May not suit non-religious entities
- No trial options available
- Limited to religious institutions
- Pricing details not publicly available
Church Pension Group provides property and casualty insurance tailored specifically for Episcopal churches and institutions. Their services focus on protecting church property and managing liability risks, mainly serving the Episcopal community.
Why I picked Church Pension Group: Church Pension Group offers insurance solutions specifically designed for Episcopal churches, ensuring that your specific needs are addressed. Their comprehensive coverage options include property protection, liability insurance, and risk management services. This specialization allows them to cater directly to Episcopal institutions, providing peace of mind and security for your church community.
Standout Services: They provide risk management training to help your team minimize potential liabilities and ensure safety. Additionally, their employee benefits consulting assists your church in managing benefits programs, which is crucial for maintaining staff satisfaction and retention.
Target industries: Episcopal churches, religious organizations, schools, dioceses, and faith-based institutions
Specialties: Property insurance, liability coverage, risk management, employee benefits, and consulting
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Dedicated to the Episcopal community
- Specialized in church property protection
- Provides employee benefits consulting
- Offers risk management training
- Tailored for Episcopal institutions
Cons:
- Detailed information requires direct inquiry
- May not serve non-Episcopal entities
- No trial offers available
- Limited to Episcopal organizations
- Pricing details not publicly available
Heffins Insurance specializes in providing insurance solutions for nonprofits and religious organizations, focusing on property, liability, and workers' compensation coverage. Their main client base includes churches and religious institutions, particularly in California.
Why I picked Heffins Insurance: Heffins Insurance is tailored specifically for churches in California, offering localized expertise and understanding of regional needs. Their coverage options include unique services like earthquake insurance, which is crucial for California-based institutions. This focus on regional requirements makes them an ideal choice for churches seeking specialized protection in this area.
Standout Services: They provide earthquake insurance to protect your church from potential seismic events, ensuring your property is safeguarded. Their event insurance covers special events and activities, providing peace of mind for your church's gatherings and outreach efforts.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, nonprofits, schools, and ministries
Specialties: Property insurance, liability coverage, workers' compensation, earthquake insurance, and event insurance
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Provides event coverage
- Strong focus on nonprofits
- Localized expertise
- Offers earthquake insurance
- Tailored for California churches
Cons:
- Detailed information requires direct inquiry
- May not suit non-religious entities
- No trial options available
- Limited to California region
- Pricing details not publicly available
Insurance Board offers insurance solutions tailored for faith-based institutions, including property, liability, and workers' compensation insurance. They primarily serve churches and other nonprofit religious organizations, focusing on risk management and protection against various liabilities.
Why I picked Insurance Board: Insurance Board is dedicated to nonprofit churches, providing specialized insurance options that cater to their unique needs. They offer services like tenants and users liability insurance, which addresses specific risks that churches face. Their focus on providing faith-based institutions with tailored solutions makes them a strong choice for nonprofit organizations.
Standout Services: They provide workers' compensation insurance that helps protect your team from work-related injuries and illnesses. Their Safety Central hub offers resources on risk management and safety guidelines, ensuring your organization is prepared for emergencies.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, nonprofit organizations, faith-based schools, and religious camps
Specialties: Property insurance, liability insurance, workers' compensation, safety resources, and risk management
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Streamlined claims process
- Nationwide network of agents
- Provides extensive safety resources
- Offers tailored insurance solutions
- Focused on faith-based institutions
Cons:
- Limited information on website
- May not serve for-profit entities well
- Trial offers require contact
- Limited to nonprofit organizations
- Pricing details not readily available
Guideone Insurance provides tailored insurance solutions for religious organizations, focusing on property, liability, and risk management services. Their main client base includes churches and faith-based institutions seeking comprehensive protection for their operations.
Why I picked Guideone Insurance: Guideone Insurance offers exceptional risk management services that help your church identify and mitigate potential risks. Their specialized coverage options, including property and liability insurance, ensure your organization is well-protected. This focus on risk management and tailored solutions makes them a valuable partner for religious institutions looking to safeguard their community and assets.
Standout Services: They offer cyber liability insurance to protect your organization from data breaches and cyber threats, which is crucial in today's digital age. Their abuse prevention program provides resources and training to help your church create a safe environment for all members.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, schools, non-profits, and faith-based institutions
Specialties: Risk management, property insurance, liability insurance, cyber liability, and abuse prevention
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Nationwide service availability
- Provides cyber liability coverage
- Tailored for religious institutions
- Offers abuse prevention resources
- Strong focus on risk management
Cons:
- Detailed information requires direct inquiry
- May not suit non-religious entities
- No trial options available
- Limited to religious organizations
- Pricing details not publicly available
Integrity Now Insurance Brokers offers specialized insurance coverage for churches, focusing on property, liability, and workers' compensation. Their main client base includes churches and religious organizations seeking personalized service and tailored insurance solutions.
Why I picked Integrity Now Insurance Brokers: Integrity Now Insurance Brokers provides a highly personalized approach to church insurance, ensuring your team receives tailored advice and support. They offer detailed consultations to help you understand the specific risks your church faces and choose the appropriate coverage. Their commitment to personal service means you can expect attentive support and customized solutions for your insurance needs.
Standout Services: They provide ministry liability coverage that protects your church from potential legal claims, ensuring your activities are safeguarded. Their property insurance covers physical assets, providing peace of mind for your church's facilities and equipment.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, non-profits, faith-based schools, and ministries
Specialties: Property insurance, liability coverage, workers' compensation, personalized consultations, and ministry liability
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Attentive customer support
- Provides detailed consultations
- Strong focus on church needs
- Tailored insurance solutions
- Offers personalized service
Cons:
- Detailed information requires direct inquiry
- May not suit non-religious entities
- No trial options available
- Limited to religious organizations
- Pricing details not publicly available
Brotherhood Mutual provides insurance solutions tailored for churches and related ministries, focusing on property, liability, and workers' compensation insurance. They primarily serve religious organizations, offering comprehensive risk management services.
Why I picked Brotherhood Mutual: Brotherhood Mutual is well-regarded for its legal assistance services, which provide churches with invaluable support. They offer legal advisory services that help your team navigate complex legal challenges specific to religious organizations. This focus on legal support is crucial for churches looking to protect their interests and ensure compliance with regulations.
Standout Services: Their ministry payroll services are designed to assist your church with payroll processing and tax reporting, ensuring compliance with financial regulations. Additionally, travel assistance services offer support for mission trips, covering risks associated with international travel and providing peace of mind.
Target industries: Churches, ministries, religious schools, mission organizations, and faith-based camps
Specialties: Property insurance, liability insurance, workers' compensation, legal assistance, and risk management
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Tailored solutions for religious organizations
- Extensive risk management resources
- Nationwide coverage
- Offers ministry-specific services
- Strong focus on legal assistance
Cons:
- Detailed information requires direct inquiry
- May not suit non-religious nonprofits
- Focus mainly on religious entities
- Limited trial options
- Pricing not publicly available
Other Church Insurance Providers
Here are some additional church insurance providers that didn’t make it onto my shortlist, but are still worth checking out:
- World Insurance
For custom coverage
- Insureon
For online insurance quotes
- Zensurance
For Canadian church coverage
- Hummel Group
For affordable church insurance
- Great American Insurance Group
For specialty human services
- Church Mutual
For religious school insurance
What Do Church Insurance Providers Typically Offer?
Church insurance providers are specialized services offering insurance coverage tailored to the unique needs of religious organizations. They might offer things like:
- Property insurance for buildings and contents
- Liability coverage for church activities
- Workers' compensation for church staff
- Cyber liability protection for digital assets
Churches, religious organizations, and faith-based schools typically seek out church insurance providers to protect their assets and manage risks associated with their operations. These services address needs like safeguarding property, ensuring liability protection, and managing employee-related risks.
Church Insurance Providers Selection Criteria
When selecting the best church insurance providers to include in this list, I considered common business needs and pain points that these providers address. This included things like mitigating liability risks and protecting property assets. I also used the following framework to keep my evaluation structured and fair:
Core Services (25% of total score)
To be considered for inclusion in this list, each provider had to offer these basic services:
- Property insurance
- Liability coverage
- Workers' compensation
- Risk management
- Accident insurance
Additional Standout Services (25% of total score)
To help further narrow down the competition, I also looked for unique or especially valuable services, such as:
- Cyber liability protection
- Abuse prevention programs
- Event insurance
- Legal assistance services
- Customizable policy options
Industry Experience (10% of total score)
To get a sense of the industry experience of each provider, I considered the following:
- Years in business
- Number of churches served
- Specialization in religious organizations
- Range of services offered
- Expertise in risk management
Onboarding (10% of total score)
To evaluate the onboarding experience for each provider, I considered the following:
- Ease of policy setup
- Availability of support during onboarding
- Clarity of policy documentation
- Speed of implementation
- Training resources provided
Customer Support (10% of total score)
To assess the level of customer support each provider offers, I considered the following:
- Availability of support channels
- Response time to inquiries
- Knowledgeability of support staff
- Availability of dedicated account managers
- Support for claims processing
Value For Price (10% of total score)
To evaluate the pricing and potential ROI of working with each provider, I considered the following:
- Competitiveness of pricing
- Range of services included in base price
- Flexibility in payment options
- Transparency of pricing structure
- Discounts for multi-policy holders
Customer Reviews (10% of total score)
To get a sense of the overall satisfaction of existing customers, I considered the following when reading customer reviews:
- Satisfaction with claims handling
- Feedback on customer service
- Ease of policy management
- Value for money
- Overall trust in the provider
Related Reviews
If you still haven’t found what you’re looking for here, check out these other tools that we’ve tested and evaluated:
How to Choose a Church Insurance Providers
It’s easy to get bogged down in long lists of services and complex pricing structures. To help you prioritize the things that matter most for your business, keep the following factors in mind:
| Factor | What to Consider |
| Business Objectives | Ensure the provider aligns with your church's mission and goals. Consider if they offer specialized services that cater to the unique needs of religious organizations. |
| Service Scope and SLAs | Check the range of services offered and the service level agreements. Ensure they cover all areas of risk your church might face, from property to liability. |
| Support Availability | Look for providers with 24/7 support. Quick response times and knowledgeable staff can be crucial during emergencies or when filing claims. |
| Costs and Pricing Structure | Understand the pricing structure and ensure transparency. Compare costs with competitors and check for hidden fees or charges that might affect your budget. |
| Communication and Reporting | Choose a provider that offers clear communication and regular reporting. This helps you stay informed about your policy and any changes that might affect coverage. |
| Customization Options | Consider if the provider allows policy customization. Tailored coverage can better meet the specific needs of your church and offer more relevant protection. |
| Claims Handling | Investigate their claims process. Efficient claims handling can save your team time and stress during incidents, ensuring quick resolutions and minimal disruptions. |
| Reputation and Reviews | Research customer reviews and the provider's reputation in the industry. This can provide insights into customer satisfaction and reliability of their services. |
Key Church Insurance Providers Services
When selecting a church insurance provider, keep an eye out for the following key services:
- Property insurance: Covers damages to church buildings and contents, protecting your physical assets from unforeseen events.
- Liability coverage: Provides protection against legal claims related to accidents or injuries that occur on church property.
- Workers' compensation: Offers coverage for medical expenses and lost wages for church employees injured while performing their duties.
- Cyber liability protection: Safeguards your church from data breaches and cyber threats, ensuring your digital information remains secure.
- Event insurance: Covers special events and activities, providing peace of mind for gatherings and outreach efforts.
- Risk management: Helps your church identify and mitigate potential risks, reducing the likelihood of incidents.
- Abuse prevention programs: Provides resources and training to create a safe environment for all church members.
- Legal assistance services: Offers support in navigating legal challenges, ensuring your church complies with regulations.
- Customizable policy options: Allows you to tailor coverage to meet the specific needs of your church, ensuring relevant protection.
- Claims handling: Ensures efficient processing of claims, minimizing disruptions and providing quick resolutions during incidents.
Benefits of Church Insurance Providers
Partnering with a church insurance provider offers several benefits for your team and your business. Here are a few you can look forward to:
- Asset protection: Safeguards your church's physical and digital assets through property and cyber liability insurance.
- Risk reduction: Helps identify and mitigate potential risks with risk management services, reducing incidents and liabilities.
- Legal support: Provides assistance in navigating legal challenges, ensuring compliance with laws and regulations through legal assistance services.
- Event security: Offers coverage for special events and activities, providing peace of mind with event insurance.
- Employee welfare: Ensures your staff is protected with workers' compensation, covering medical expenses and lost wages.
- Tailored coverage: Allows customization of policies to meet specific church needs, ensuring relevant and effective protection.
- Community safety: Enhances safety with abuse prevention programs, creating a secure environment for all members.
Costs and Pricing Structures of Church Insurance Providers
Church insurance providers typically come at a custom price to accommodate various business needs, sizes, and circumstances. Providers generally work within one of the following pricing structures:
- Custom pricing: Tailored quotes based on the specific needs and risks of your church.
- Flat fee: A fixed price for a set package of services, offering predictability in budgeting.
- Tiered pricing: Different levels of coverage at varying prices, allowing you to select the best fit for your budget.
- Pay-as-you-go: Charges based on actual usage or claims, which can be ideal for smaller churches with fluctuating needs.
- Discounts for multi-policy: Reduced rates when bundling multiple types of insurance under one provider.
Key Factors That Influence Church Insurance Providers Pricing
Beyond the specific pricing model, here are some additional factors that can influence the cost of church insurance providers:
- Customization level: Tailoring coverage to meet specific church needs can increase costs due to the specialized nature of the policies.
- Risk exposure: Churches with higher risk activities or locations might face higher premiums to cover potential liabilities.
- Property value: The value of your church's property and assets can affect insurance costs, as higher value properties might require more coverage.
- Number of employees: More staff can lead to higher costs for workers' compensation and liability coverage.
- Compliance requirements: Adhering to specific industry regulations or standards may require additional coverage, impacting overall costs.
Being aware of these factors before you start seeking out custom quotes from providers helps you get a sense of what to expect, and compare and contrast quotes more effectively.
Church Insurance Providers: FAQs
Here are some answers to common questions about church insurance providers:
What types of coverage do church insurance providers offer?
Church insurance providers typically offer a range of coverage options to protect your church’s assets and operations. This includes property insurance for buildings and contents, liability coverage for accidents and injuries, and workers’ compensation for staff. You might also find specialized options like cyber liability and event insurance to address specific risks.
How do I choose the right church insurance provider?
When choosing a church insurance provider, consider factors like the types of coverage they offer, their experience in the industry, and the level of customer support they provide. It’s important to compare pricing structures and ensure they offer policies that match your church’s specific needs. Consulting with other churches or seeking recommendations can also help in making an informed decision.
How often should we review our church insurance policy?
It’s advisable to review your church insurance policy annually or whenever there are significant changes to your church’s operations or assets. Regular reviews ensure that your coverage remains adequate and that you’re not overpaying for unnecessary coverage. Changes in regulations or new activities at your church might also require adjustments to your policy.
Can church insurance providers help with risk management?
Yes, many church insurance providers offer risk management services as part of their offerings. These services can help you identify potential risks and implement strategies to mitigate them, reducing the likelihood of incidents. Risk management support might include training resources, safety assessments, and advice on best practices.
What should we do if we need to file a claim?
If you need to file a claim, contact your insurance provider as soon as possible to report the incident. They will guide you through the claims process, which usually involves providing documentation and details about the event. It’s important to keep records of all communications and follow the provider’s instructions to ensure a smooth claims process.
Are there discounts available for churches?
Many church insurance providers offer discounts for churches that bundle multiple policies or demonstrate strong risk management practices. It’s worth asking about available discounts during your initial consultation with a provider. Some providers also offer reduced rates for certain types of coverage or for churches that meet specific criteria.
What's Next?
Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest resources, best practices, and insights on managing churches from expert pastors and church leaders.