15 Best Nonprofit Consulting Firms Reviewed in 2025
Best Nonprofit Consulting Firms Shortlist
Here’s my shortlist of the best nonprofit consulting firms:
Get free help from our service advisors to find your match.
Keeping a church running smoothly isn’t easy. One moment, you’re handling budgets; the next, you’re managing staff, planning events, or dealing with unexpected challenges. On top of that, tasks like human resources, financial audits, and long-term planning can quickly become overwhelming. With so much on your plate, it’s hard to keep up.
That’s where the right full-service consulting partner can help. More than just offering advice, they provide hands-on solutions for strategic planning, leadership development, financial management, and even HR support—so you can stay focused on your mission with confidence.
I’ve put together a list of top consulting firms that specialize in helping churches. Whether you need a big-picture strategy, compliance audits, or help with day-to-day operations, these experts can help lighten the load and strengthen your ministry.
Need expert help selecting the right tool?
With one-on-one help, we guide you to your top software options. Narrow down your software search & make a confident choice.
Why Trust Our Reviews
We’ve reviewed church management software and services since 2019. As church managers, we know how tough it is to choose the right provider. Our research covers social impact, board development, and more to help you make the best decision.
We’ve tested more than 2,000 tools and hundreds of service providers for different church management use cases, and written over 1,000 comprehensive reviews. Learn how we stay transparent & check out our review methodology.
Best Nonprofit Consulting Firm Reviews
Below are my detailed summaries of the best nonprofit consulting firms that made it onto my shortlist. My reviews offer a look at each provider’s key services, unique specialties, and pros & cons to help you find the best one for your needs.
Christian Ministry Alliance provides outsourced consulting for nonprofits, NGOs, and churches, helping reduce operational burdens so organizations can focus on their mission. They offer comprehensive assessments of systems, culture, and goals, delivering actionable recommendations and coaching tailored for the social sector.
Why I picked Christian Ministry Alliance: They specialize in faith-based compliance, offering services that help your team align operations with mission goals. Their four-step process—Discovery, Plan Creation, Culture Shifting, and Sustained Efficiency—ensures a structured approach to improving operational systems. By providing ongoing support, they help you achieve sustainable growth in your mission-driven activities.
Standout Services: They offer fiscal sponsorship to help your team manage financial responsibilities while focusing on mission-related tasks. Their bookkeeping services address the challenge of maintaining accurate financial records, providing expertise to ensure compliance and efficiency.
Target industries: Non-profits, churches, and faith-based organizations
Specialties: Operational efficiency, faith-based compliance, fiscal sponsorship, bookkeeping, and strategic planning
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Provides bookkeeping services
- Offers fiscal sponsorship
- Structured four-step process
- Tailored for faith-based organizations
- Supports sustainable growth
Cons:
- Focused primarily on operational efficiency
- May not suit all organization sizes
- Requires consultation for specifics
- Pricing details not available online
Ministry Architects offers consulting services for sustainable youth and children's ministries, strategic planning, staffing solutions, and fundraising consulting. They help churches and faith-based organizations with major donor strategies and messaging to strengthen ministry programs.
Why I picked Ministry Architects: They are known for supporting youth ministries by offering tailored strategies to build sustainable programs that align with your church's mission. Their focus on strategic planning ensures that your team can create a clear roadmap for ministry growth. By providing staffing solutions, they help you find and retain the right leaders for your youth programs.
Standout Services: They offer visioning summits to help your team clarify goals and set actionable plans for your ministry. Their assessment services provide insights into your current ministry status, identifying areas for improvement and growth.
Target industries: Churches, faith-based organizations, and religious communities
Specialties: Youth ministry, children's ministry, strategic planning, staffing solutions, and visioning
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Emphasizes strategic planning
- Provides staffing solutions
- Offers visioning summits
- Focus on sustainable program development
- Tailored strategies for youth ministries
Cons:
- Primarily focused on youth and children's ministries
- Requires consultation for specific needs
- May not suit all ministry sizes
- Pricing details not available online
The Center Consulting Group helps churches, religious organizations, and higher education institutions improve organizational health through leadership development, team building, and strategic planning. Their services also include social media guidance and feasibility studies to enhance operations and leadership.
Why I picked The Center Consulting Group: They focus on organizational health, providing leadership development and team-building services that align with your church's values. Their strategic planning ensures your leadership team has a clear roadmap for growth and development. By addressing internal dynamics, they help you foster a healthier organizational culture.
Standout Services: They offer conflict resolution workshops to help your team navigate and resolve internal disputes effectively. Their leadership retreats provide an immersive experience for developing leadership skills and fostering team cohesion.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, and faith-based institutions
Specialties: Organizational health, leadership development, team building, strategic planning, and conflict resolution
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Consultation available
- Emphasizes team building
- Provides leadership retreats
- Offers conflict resolution workshops
- Focus on organizational health
Cons:
- Primarily focused on internal operations
- May not suit all organization sizes
- Requires consultation for specifics
- Pricing details not disclosed
Barna provides consulting services with actionable recommendations based on tailored research. They help businesses, nonprofits, and churches with capacity building, capital campaigns, and understanding faith-related psychographics.
Why I picked Barna: They excel in data-driven insights, offering custom research and strategic planning to help you understand your community's unique dynamics. Their leadership development services empower your team to address contemporary challenges effectively. With a focus on generational dynamics, Barna provides valuable perspectives that aid in strategic decision-making.
Standout Services: They provide custom research to help your team gain insights specific to your organization's context. Their leadership development programs are designed to equip your leaders with the skills needed to navigate complex challenges.
Target industries: Churches, nonprofits, businesses, and religious organizations
Specialties: Custom research, leadership development, strategic planning, community assessments, and generational dynamics
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Discovery call available
- Offers custom research services
- Expertise in generational dynamics
- Tailored consulting solutions
- Focus on data-driven insights
Cons:
- May not suit all organizational types
- Requires contact for detailed information
- Limited to faith-based psychographics
- May focus heavily on data analysis
- Pricing details not available online
LeaderPerfect is a fundraising consulting firm specializing in leadership development, executive coaching, and strategic planning. They help nonprofits navigate transitions, improve metrics, and strengthen their strategic direction to enhance leadership capabilities.
Why I picked LeaderPerfect: They specialize in executive training, providing leadership development programs tailored to your organization's needs. Their strategic planning services ensure your team has a clear path to achieving its goals. By offering executive coaching, they help you enhance decision-making and leadership skills within your team.
Standout Services: They offer team-building workshops to help your team improve collaboration and communication. Their conflict management training equips your leaders with skills to handle disputes effectively, fostering a harmonious work environment.
Target industries: Nonprofits, educational institutions, healthcare organizations, and government agencies
Specialties: Leadership development, executive coaching, strategic planning, team building, and conflict management
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Free consultation available
- Tailored leadership programs
- Provides conflict management training
- Offers team-building workshops
- Focus on executive training
Cons:
- Primarily focused on nonprofits
- May not suit all organization sizes
- Requires consultation for specifics
- Limited to leadership-focused services
- Pricing details not disclosed
The Unstuck Group helps churches overcome growth barriers and stay mission-focused. Their consulting services cover strategic planning, staffing, leadership development, Salesforce integration, and giving programs, primarily serving churches and faith-based organizations.
Why I picked The Unstuck Group: They focus on growth strategies, providing tools and frameworks to help your team navigate challenges and seize opportunities for expansion. Their strategic planning services ensure your church's mission is supported by actionable goals. By offering leadership development, they equip your team with the skills necessary to drive growth and foster a thriving church environment.
Standout Services: They provide health assessments to help your team understand the current state of your church and identify areas for improvement. Their staffing and structure reviews offer insights into optimizing your organizational structure for better efficiency and effectiveness.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, and faith-based institutions
Specialties: Growth strategies, strategic planning, leadership development, health assessments, and staffing reviews
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Free consultation available
- Emphasizes leadership development
- Provides staffing and structure reviews
- Offers health assessments
- Focus on growth strategies
Cons:
- Primarily focused on growth and planning
- May not suit all organization sizes
- Requires consultation for specifics
- Pricing details not disclosed
Recentered Group equips church leaders and boards with the tools to foster trust, navigate challenges, and build a disciple-making culture. They specialize in addressing church-specific issues such as leadership conflicts, governance struggles, and toxic cultures.
Why I picked Recentered Group: Their approach is deeply rooted in church health, focusing on high-trust relationships and discipleship. Unlike generic leadership consultants, Recentered Group tailors its strategies specifically for church environments, helping pastors and leadership teams strengthen their ministries.
Standout Services: Recentered Group equips churches with discipleship training, church health assessments, and leadership coaching to foster growth and unity. Their hands-on approach helps leaders identify strengths, address challenges, and build a thriving ministry.
Target industries: Churches, faith-based organizations, and christian communities seeking expert guidance on leadership, governance, and spiritual formation.
Specialties: They specialize in church leadership support, discipleship development, and church health assessments to strengthen ministries. Additionally, they offer conflict resolution and trust-building services to help churches foster unity and effective teamwork.
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Free consultation available
- Provides health assessments
- Offers discipleship courses
- Emphasis on high-trust relationships
Cons:
- Focused primarily on internal church leadership dynamics
- No online pricing tool
- Pricing details not listed
Nelson / Kraft & Associates specializes in helping mission-driven organizations strengthen their leadership teams and refine their strategies for greater impact. With a deep understanding of the nonprofit and faith-based sectors, they offer executive search, succession planning, and strategic consulting to ensure organizations are equipped with strong, purpose-driven leadership.
Why I picked Nelson / Kraft & Associates: Their expertise goes beyond simply filling leadership roles—they take a holistic approach, ensuring each placement aligns with an organization’s mission, culture, and long-term goals. Their consulting services also help nonprofits navigate transitions, improve governance, and develop sustainable strategies for growth.
Standout Services: Nelson / Kraft & Associates specializes in executive search and succession planning, ensuring organizations find mission-driven leaders. Their strategic consulting helps refine vision, improve operations, and drive sustainable growth. They also provide board development support to strengthen governance and leadership effectiveness.
Target Industries: Nonprofits, churches, faith-based organizations, and mission-driven enterprises seeking expert guidance in leadership transitions and organizational strategy.
Specialties: Nelson / Kraft & Associates specializes in nonprofit executive search, leadership succession planning, strategic consulting, and board governance to help organizations build strong, effective leadership teams.
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Free consultation available
- Offers strategic consulting beyond recruitment
- Focus on mission-aligned leadership placements
- Deep expertise in nonprofit leadership transitions
Cons:
- Primarily focused on leadership and governance, not day-to-day operations
- No online pricing tool
- Pricing details not listed
Auxano helps churches clarify their vision and align strategies with their mission. They guide churches and religious organizations in strategic planning, leadership development, CRM solutions, and fundraising efforts—all to advance social good.
Why I picked Auxano: They excel in providing vision clarity, offering services that help your team articulate and implement your church's mission effectively. Their strategic planning workshops ensure that your leadership team has a clear and actionable plan for growth. By focusing on leadership development, they equip your team with the skills needed to guide your church toward its goals.
Standout Services: They offer vision framing processes to help your team define and communicate your church's unique mission and direction. Their leadership pipeline development provides tools and training to ensure a steady flow of capable leaders for your organization.
Target industries: Churches, religious organizations, and faith-based institutions
Specialties: Vision clarity, strategic planning, leadership development, mission alignment, and vision framing
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Free consultation available
- Emphasizes mission alignment
- Offers vision framing processes
- Provides leadership development tools
- Focus on vision clarity
Cons:
- Primarily focused on vision and leadership
- May not suit all organization sizes
- Requires consultation for specifics
- Pricing details not disclosed
The Malphurs Group offers consulting services focused on strategic planning, leadership development, and church revitalization. They primarily serve churches and faith-based organizations, helping them to align their mission with effective strategies.
Why I picked The Malphurs Group: They specialize in leadership coaching, providing resources and training to help your team develop strong leadership skills. Their strategic planning services ensure your church's mission aligns with actionable goals. With a focus on revitalization, they guide you through the process of renewing your church's vision and impact.
Standout Services: They offer management consulting to help your team clarify and articulate your church’s mission. Their church revitalization programs and prospect research services focus on renewing your purpose and engaging your community effectively.
Target industries: Churches, faith-based organizations, and religious institutions
Specialties: Leadership coaching, strategic planning, church revitalization, vision clarity, and mission alignment
Pros and cons
Pros:
- Free consultation available
- Emphasizes mission alignment
- Provides church revitalization programs
- Offers vision clarity processes
- Focus on leadership development
Cons:
- Primarily focused on leadership and revitalization
- Requires consultation for specific needs
- May not suit all church sizes
- Pricing details not available online
Other Nonprofit Consulting Firms
Here are some additional nonprofit consulting firms that didn’t make it onto my shortlist, but are still worth checking out:
- Elemental Group
For community engagement
- Vanderbloemen
For church staffing solutions
- Heller Consulting
For nonprofit tech strategy
- Amphil
For faith community support
- Just Outcomes Consulting
For conflict resolution
What Do Nonprofit Consulting Firms Typically Offer?
If you’ve ever felt stuck trying to run the church like a ministry and a small business at the same time, you’re not alone. Most pastors didn’t get into ministry to wrestle with budgets, strategic plans, or leadership development frameworks. That’s where nonprofit consultants come in.
They bring clarity and focus to areas where many churches quietly struggle:
- Strategic planning to align your church’s vision with practical steps
- Fundraising and grant writing support to strengthen financial health
- Leadership development to equip your staff and volunteers
- Financial management to steward resources wisely
- Marketing and communication strategies to reach your community
If your days are getting eaten up by admin fires, blurry plans, or meetings with no outcomes, a good nonprofit consulting partner can free you up to focus on your core calling—preaching, discipleship, prayer, and care.
How I Evaluated These Nonprofit Consulting Firms
Not all nonprofit consultants are created equal. Some specialize in grant writing. Others offer full-scale organizational turnarounds. So to build a helpful list for pastors, I evaluated each firm using this framework—weighted by what typically matters most in a church setting:
Core Services (25% of total score)
To be considered for inclusion in this list, providers had to offer these basic services:
- Strategic planning
- Fundraising guidance
- Leadership training
- Financial management
- Marketing strategy
Additional Standout Services (25% of total score)
Bonus points if they provided specialized value, like:
- Crisis management (for when things fall apart)
- Digital transformation (hello, database cleanup)
- Volunteer systems (finally organize your teams)
- Community outreach support
- Diversity and inclusion training (especially helpful in multi-ethnic contexts)
Sector Experience (10% of total score)
Churches aren’t like other nonprofits. I looked for:
- Experience working with churches and ministries
- Years in the nonprofit world
- Client range and case studies
- Denominational or theological familiarity
Onboarding (10% of total score)
Time matters. I evaluated:
- How clearly they explain their process
- How fast they can start
- If training or tools are included
- Whether they adapt their plan to your context
Customer Support (10% of total score)
After sign-up, you don’t want to feel ghosted. I checked for:
- Responsiveness
- Clear support channels
- Technical help when you need it
- Regular check-ins
Value For Price (10% of total score)
Ministry budgets are tight. I looked for:
- Transparent pricing
- Flexible payment models
- Clear cost-benefit and ROI
- Room to scale as you grow
Customer Reviews (10% of total score)
Finally, I leaned on what other leaders are saying:
- Consistency of positive reviews
- Complaints (and how they were handled)
- Repeat clients
- Outcomes and success stories
How to Choose a Nonprofit Consulting Firms Provider
It’s easy to get bogged down in long lists of services and complex pricing structures. To help you prioritize the things that matter most for your business, keep the following factors in mind:
| Factor | What to Consider |
|---|---|
| Mission Alignment | Do they get the heart of what your church is trying to do? |
| Clarity of Services | Are they upfront about deliverables and timelines? |
| Support Options | Can you reach them when things break down? |
| Budget Fit | Are their prices doable—and worth it? |
| Communication Style | Will they keep you updated, or will you need to chase them? |
| Customization | Can they adjust their approach to your church’s quirks? |
| Reputation | Do other pastors speak highly of them? |
| Cultural Fit | Do they work with churches like yours? Or do they treat you like just another nonprofit? |
Key Nonprofit Consulting Firms Services
If you’re scanning a firm’s site or proposal, keep an eye out for these offerings:
- Strategic planning: Not just theory, but a step-by-step plan you can follow.
- Fundraising strategy: Including digital giving and grants.
- Leadership development: Especially for volunteers and lay leaders.
- Financial oversight: Budgeting, audits, reports that actually make sense.
- Marketing support: Help with messaging, social media, website updates.
- Vision clarity: Getting your mission statement out of your head and into the life of your church.
- Conflict resolution: Tools for dealing with tension before it escalates.
- Community engagement: Ways to deepen your presence in the neighborhood.
- Digital transformation: Systems and software that don’t require a PhD.
- Volunteer management: Finally getting your people in the right seats.
Why Work With Nonprofit Consulting Firms?
Here’s the bottom line. A trustworthy nonprofit consultant brings focused help so you can:
- Raise more support with smarter, more diverse fundraising
- Develop leaders so you’re not doing everything yourself
- Clarify your vision and align your staff and systems to match
- Get your finances in order without hiring a full-time CFO
- Engage your community in ways that make people feel seen
- Resolve conflict before it turns into drama
- Upgrade your systems without getting buried in tech details
How Nonprofit Consulting Firms Price Their Services
Most nonprofit consultants price their services based on the kind of help you need. Here are the common setups:
- Project-based: One-time fee for a clear deliverable.
- Hourly rate: Pay for what you use.
- Retainer: Ongoing support for a monthly fee.
- Performance-based: Payment tied to outcomes (e.g., fundraising success).
- Subscription-based: Access to a package of services month to month.
What Affects Pricing?
Some of the biggest cost variables include:
- Customization level: Tailored plans cost more, but often save money later.
- Church size: More staff, more complexity, more hours.
- Compliance needs: Some churches need extra legal or financial oversight.
- Scope of services: A one-off consult costs less than a full strategic overhaul.
The key is knowing your goals ahead of time so you can get the right help at the right price.
Nonprofit Consulting Firms: FAQs for Pastors
You’ve got questions. Here’s what most pastors want to know before they bring in outside help.
How do I choose the right nonprofit consulting firm?
Start with clarity: What do you need help with—finances, leadership, outreach, operations? Then look for nonprofit consultants who’ve worked with churches or faith-based ministries. Read reviews from other pastors or nonprofit leaders. Pay attention to how they price their services—and whether their values align with yours. A firm that “gets” your culture will be easier to work with.
What should I expect during the first consultation?
You’ll sit down (virtually or in person) and talk through the problems you’re trying to solve. They’ll ask questions to get a sense of where things are stuck. You’ll want to ask them about their experience with churches, how they approach challenges like yours, and what kind of results they’ve seen. This meeting should help you both figure out if there’s a good fit.
How long does a typical consulting engagement last?
It depends on what you need. A focused project—like revamping your volunteer structure—might take a few weeks. Bigger efforts—like creating a strategic plan or overhauling your budget process—could take a few months. The key is to get clear timelines up front, and keep expectations realistic.
Can nonprofit consultants help with fundraising?
Absolutely. Many nonprofit consulting firms offer hands-on help with fundraising—everything from donor communication to grant strategy. They can help identify new revenue streams, refine your messaging, or run capital campaigns. If funding is a stress point (and for most pastors, it is), make sure fundraising is in their toolbox.
How do consulting firms measure success?
The good ones don’t talk in vague terms. They tie their work to clear outcomes: more giving, better leadership, tighter operations, a healthier budget, stronger volunteer teams. You’ll usually agree on the goals at the start. Then you’ll check progress along the way, and adjust if needed.
What role does my team play during a consulting engagement?
Your team isn’t just along for the ride—they’re in the driver’s seat with you. The consultants bring the tools, but your staff and key leaders will need to help shape the plan and carry it out. A successful engagement takes honest feedback, good communication, and a willingness to change what’s not working.
What's Next?
Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest resources, best practices, and insights on managing churches from expert pastors and church leaders.