Givelify vs. Tithely: Comparison and Expert Reviews for 2026
We review tools independently, and commissions help fund our testing. See our transparency policy, our methodology, or suggest a tool.
If you’re searching for a better way to manage donations, you know how overwhelming it can feel to choose the right church giving software. Givelify and Tithely both promise to make giving easier for your congregation, but each takes a different approach to features, pricing, and support. You want a giving solution that fits your ministry’s needs, budget, and the way your people donate.
In this article, you’ll get a clear comparison of Givelify and Tithely—including pros and cons, use cases, pricing, security, and usability. I’ll help you see which platform aligns best with your church’s goals and challenges.
Givelify
4.8/5
- Free plan available
- From 2.9% + $0.30 per donation
Tithe.ly
4.7/5
- 30-day free trial available
- From $72/month
Why Trust Our Software Recommendations
6,700+
Reviews
20
Industry experts
16+
Evaluation factors
14
Years
Our team has been testing and reviewing software since 2012. As church leaders ourselves, we know how difficult—and important—it is to choose the right software.
For this guide, we evaluated tools using hands-on testing and independent research, scoring tools using our selection criteria.
Our reviews reflect our human editorial judgment, not a sales pitch.
| Givelify | Tithe.ly | |
|---|---|---|
| Free Trial | Free plan available | 30-day free trial available |
| Pricing | From 2.9% + $0.30 per donation | From $72/month |
Givelify vs. Tithely Pricing & Hidden Costs
Givelify uses a simple transaction fee model, so you only pay when someone gives—there are no monthly subscriptions or setup fees. Tithely, on the other hand, offers a mix of monthly plans and transaction fees, with extra charges for certain features like text giving or church management tools.
To choose between these giving solutions, start by mapping out your church’s giving patterns and the features you actually need. Review each platform’s fee structure, ask about any add-ons or contract terms, and calculate the total cost based on your expected donation volume. This approach helps you avoid surprises and ensures you’re investing in a solution that truly fits your ministry’s size and goals.
Both Givelify and Tithely offer key features like easy online giving, mobile apps for donors, and tools to track donations and generate reports. You’ll find recurring giving, donor management, and integration with your church’s website on both platforms. These shared features help you simplify giving and keep your records organized.
Givelify stands out with its focus on a fast, three-tap giving experience and a user-friendly app that appeals to first-time givers in church and nonprofit settings. Tithely, meanwhile, offers a broader suite of tools, including event registration, text-to-give, and full church management features (like directories for organizing church members and communication tools). These unique strengths can make a big difference depending on your church’s needs.
| Givelify | Tithe.ly | |
|---|---|---|
| API | No | No |
| Calendar Management | No | No |
| Contact Management | Yes | No |
| Dashboards | Yes | No |
| Data Export | Yes | Yes |
| Data Import | Yes | Yes |
| Document Management | No | No |
| External Integrations | Yes | Yes |
| Multi-User | Yes | Yes |
| Notifications | Yes | Yes |
| Payment Gateway Integration | Yes | No |
| Scheduling | Yes | No |
| Workflow Management | No | No |
| Integration | Givelify | Tithely |
| QuickBooks | ❌ | ✅ |
| Planning Center | ❌ | ✅ |
| Mailchimp | ❌ | ❌ |
| Church Community Builder | ❌ | ✅ |
| Rock RMS | ❌ | ✅ |
| FellowshipOne | ❌ | ✅ |
| Elvanto | ❌ | ✅ |
| StudioC | ❌ | ✅ |
| API | ✅ | ✅ |
| Zapier | ❌ | ✅ |
Tithely offers a much wider range of direct integrations with popular church management and accounting tools, while Givelify focuses on its core giving platform and provides API access for custom connections.
If your church relies on connecting giving data to other systems and prefers a more plug-and-play approach, Tithely’s integration options will likely meet your needs more easily. However, Givelify’s API can still support custom workflows for tech-savvy teams.
| Factor | Givelify | Tithely |
| Payment Encryption | Uses PCI-compliant, bank-level encryption for all transactions. | Secures all transactions with PCI DSS compliance and advanced encryption protocols. |
| Data Privacy | Adheres to strict privacy policies and does not share donor data. | Follows GDPR and privacy best practices, giving churches control over donor information. |
| Uptime Reliability | Maintains high uptime with cloud-based infrastructure and real-time monitoring. | Offers high uptime and robust cloud hosting for uninterrupted giving. |
| Regulatory Compliance | Meets U.S. financial regulations for charitable giving. | Complies with U.S. and international giving regulations, including tax receipt automation. |
| Fraud Protection | Monitors for suspicious activity and provides secure donor authentication. | Includes fraud detection tools and multi-factor authentication for added security. |
Each provider delivers strong security and compliance, but Tithely stands out with broader regulatory coverage and more advanced fraud protection. Givelify’s strength is its simple, transparent approach to privacy and reliability, while Tithely excels in offering extra layers of compliance and security for larger or international churches.
| Factor | Givelify | Tithely |
| User Interface | Features a clean, intuitive app with a three-tap giving process. | Offers a modern dashboard with more features, but a slightly steeper learning curve. |
| Onboarding | Quick setup with minimal steps and clear instructions for new users. | Provides guided onboarding and tutorials, but setup can take longer due to more options. |
| Donor Experience | Prioritizes speed and simplicity for donors of all ages. | Allows donors to give in multiple ways, but some may find the options overwhelming at first. |
| Admin Management | Simple reporting and management tools designed for ease of use. | Advanced admin features with customizable settings, which may require more training. |
| Customer Support | Responsive support via email and help center resources. | Offers live chat, email, and a detailed knowledge base for ongoing support. |
Givelify is the clear winner for simplicity and speed, while Tithely shines for churches that want more features and don’t mind a bit of a learning curve. Givelify is known for its effortless donor experience, while Tithely’s robust platform rewards those willing to invest time in setup and training.
Givelify
- You can easily navigate its user-friendly interface.
- It offers quick donation processing for your church.
- Your donors appreciate its simple mobile app for giving.
- You might find limited customization options for donation forms.
- Your team may experience occasional delays in customer support responses.
- The onboarding process could be more comprehensive for new users.
Tithe.ly
- The user-friendly interface makes donations and fundraising easy for your team.
- Customizable donation forms enhance your donor's experience.
- Strong donor management features support your church's financial tracking needs.
- Some users report technical glitches that may disrupt your workflow.
- Limited features compared to other platforms might not meet all your needs.
- Users seek more advanced reporting tools to better analyze contributions.
Givelify
- Small ChurchesGivelify's simplicity and ease of use are ideal for small churches that need a straightforward donation process.
- Community GroupsIf your group needs a user-friendly platform for collecting funds, Givelify's mobile app makes it easy for members to contribute.
- Non-Tech Savvy UsersGivelify's intuitive design ensures that even those unfamiliar with tech can navigate it without frustration.
- Mobile-First DonorsDonors who prefer using their phones for transactions will appreciate Givelify's efficient mobile app.
- Event FundraisersWith Givelify, you can quickly set up donation campaigns for events, making it a great choice for event-based fundraising.
- Volunteer-Run OrganizationVolunteer teams will find Givelify's simple onboarding and minimal management hassle-free, allowing them to focus on their mission.
Tithe.ly
- Small ChurchesTithe.ly is ideal for small churches needing a simple, cost-effective way to manage donations and engage their community.
- Mid-Sized CongregationsMid-sized congregations benefit from Tithe.ly's robust donor management and customizable forms to enhance member contributions.
- Church Finance TeamsFinance teams use Tithe.ly to track donations efficiently, thanks to its strong reporting capabilities and user-friendly interface.
- Nonprofit OrganizationsNonprofits find Tithe.ly valuable for its donation tracking and management features that support fundraising efforts.
- Religious SchoolsReligious schools can use Tithe.ly to streamline fundraising campaigns, leveraging its customizable donation forms.
- Community CentersCommunity centers benefit from Tithe.ly’s straightforward platform to handle contributions and support ongoing projects.
Who Should Use Givelify, and Who Should Use Tithely?
Givelify is the best fit for churches that want a fast, no-fuss giving and fundraising experience and don’t need complex integrations or extra church management tools. If your congregation values simplicity, or you’re working with limited tech resources, Givelify keeps things easy for both donors and admins.
Tithely is ideal for churches looking for an all-in-one church management software solution with advanced features, deep integrations, and tools to manage everything from giving and event management to communications and church website building. Choose Tithely if you have a larger team, need more customization, or want to centralize your church operations in one place.
| Givelify | Tithe.ly | |
|---|---|---|
| Customization | Givelify Minimal customization functionality, designed for out-of-the-box use. | Tithe.ly Highly customizable with options for branding, workflows, and donor engagement tools. |
| Feature Set | Givelify The Givelify app and platform focus on simple giving and donation tracking. | Tithe.ly Offers a full suite, including online donations, events, church management, and communication tools. |
| Integrations | Givelify Limited direct integrations, but provides API access. | Tithe.ly Integrates with many church management and accounting platforms, plus Zapier for automation. |
| Pricing Model | Givelify Charges only transaction fees with no monthly subscription. | Tithe.ly Uses a mix of monthly plans and transaction fees, with extra charges for advanced features. |
| User Experience | Givelify Prioritizes a fast, three-tap giving process for donors. | Tithe.ly Provides a feature-rich dashboard that may require more training to master. |
| Donation Management | Both provide real-time donation tracking and reporting, helping church leaders monitor giving trends and generate statements for donors. |
|---|---|
| Donor Management | Each tool includes basic donor management features, letting you view giving history, manage donor profiles, and send thank-you messages. |
| Mobile Giving App | Both offer user-friendly mobile apps (iOS and Android) that let donors give anytime, anywhere. |
| Recurring Donations | Each platform allows donors to set up automatic, recurring gifts, making regular digital giving simple for supporters and predictable for churches. |
| Secure Transactions | Givelify and Tithely use PCI-compliant encryption and fraud protection to keep donor information and transactions safe. |